What a new roof costs in north Missouri

CK's Construction

Most people asking this want one number, and the honest answer is that the material on your roof costs about two dollars a square foot whether you go metal or shingles — and that the material is the part nobody argues about. What moves your price is how big the roof is, how many cuts and planes are in it, and what turns up when the old roof comes off.

That last one is why nobody can price your roof over the phone.

The part that surprises people

Metal has a reputation for costing two or three times what shingles do. In the field of the roof — the open area that actually covers your house — it does not.

Here is what the covering itself comes to on one of our quotes, per square foot of roof — the material line, before any labor:

Material, per sq ft
Architectural shingles about $1.80
26 gauge smooth metal about $1.89
26 gauge textured metal about $2.02
26 gauge woodgrain ag panel about $3.19

Eight cents a square foot between a shingle roof and a smooth metal one. On a two thousand square foot roof that is about a hundred and sixty dollars of difference in the covering.

Under either one goes an underlayment, and it is cheap for what it does: about 13 cents a square foot for the synthetic felt that goes under shingles, about 24 cents for the moisture barrier that goes under metal.

So where does the reputation come from? The edges. A shingle roof needs starter course, ridge caps, drip edge and ice-and-water shield at the eaves and valleys. A metal roof needs ridge cap, rake trim, gutter apron, endwall and sidewall trim, closures, screws and — over a tear-off — battens. Those are priced by the piece and by the foot, and a roof with six planes and four valleys eats a great deal more of them than a plain gable does.

That is the whole thing in one line: the field of the roof costs about the same either way. The difference is in the edges, the labor and how long it lasts.

We build everything in 26 gauge. It is the heavier of the two gauges commonly used on roofs around here, and it goes on every job we do, barn or house.

Why we do not publish an installed price per square foot

Because we would be making it up, and you would find out.

Roof labor does not scale with area the way material does. Two roofs of the same square footage can be a day apart in work if one is a plain gable and the other has dormers, valleys, a chimney and three changes of pitch. Every cut is a flashing detail, and flashing details are where roofs leak and where the hours go. A builder who quotes you a flat dollar-per-square-foot over the phone has either not looked at your roof or is building a cushion into it.

For what it is worth, the trade puts asphalt shingles at $1.50 to $6 a square foot installed and metal at $4 to $30 — the trade’s figures, not ours, and they cover the whole country.

Tearing off against going over

We priced one roof both ways this summer, same house, same metal package. Tearing the old roof off first came to about a third more than going over the top of it. The customer went over the top, and it was the right call on that house.

Not all of that third is the tear-off itself — the dearer version also picked up framing repairs the tear-off exposed. But it is a fair picture of the gap, and it is a real pair of quotes with a real decision at the end, not a rule of thumb.

Going over works when there is one layer up there, the decking is sound and the framing can carry the weight. It is not a trick and it is not cutting a corner. What goes between is a moisture barrier and 1x4 battens two feet on center, which gives the metal an air gap to breathe through.

The number that is not in anybody’s quote

Bad decking. On our shingle work it is replaced at $50 a sheet, and nobody — us included — knows how many sheets until the old roof is off.

That is the single most common reason a roof price moves after the start. A builder who has thought about it will tell you his per-sheet price up front. Ask for it. A builder who has not thought about it will tell you it probably will not happen.

What is actually in a proper shingle roof

Worth knowing, because this is where a cheap quote gets cheap:

  • The old shingles off and gone
  • Loose decking re-nailed, bad sheets replaced
  • Ice and water shield at all eaves and valleys
  • Synthetic underlayment over the rest
  • Drip edge and gutter apron
  • Starter shingles along the eaves
  • Architectural shingles, with matching ridge shingles
  • New venting
  • New pipe and chimney flashings
  • All the debris hauled away
  • A written workmanship warranty on top of the manufacturer’s

If a quote does not say ice and water shield, ask where it is going. If it does not mention flashings, ask what is happening at the chimney.

What we would actually do

Come and look at it, get on it if it is safe to, and tell you what is up there before quoting anything. If one layer is up and the decking is sound we will price it both ways and let you see the gap for yourself, the way we did on that roof this summer.

And if the honest answer is that your roof has five good years left and wants a flashing detail fixed rather than replacing, we would rather sell you the repair and have the reroof when it is genuinely due.

Next step

Tell Us About Your Project!

We understand that investing in a build is a big decision. We offer a complimentary consultation where we will gather the scope of your project, ideal timeline, and budget.