Metal roof vs shingles: which is cheaper over thirty years?

CK's Construction

Metal costs more to put on. Shingles cost less today and get bought again later. That is the whole argument, and both sides of it are true.

The useful question is not “which is cheaper.” It is how long are you going to be under it. Answer that honestly and the rest falls out.

We build both, and we will tell you which one your situation actually calls for.

How long each one lasts

  • Architectural asphalt shingles: 20 to 30 years. In this part of the state, call it the lower half of that. Hail, hard freezes and a hot July are all hard on shingles.
  • Steel metal roofing: 40 to 80 years. The panel outlives the person who chose it, and usually outlives the fasteners, which is a maintenance job rather than a replacement.

Those are the trade’s numbers, not ours, and they are consistent everywhere you look.

The thirty-year arithmetic

Take a thirty-year window and it comes out like this:

With metal, you buy one roof. At year thirty it is middle-aged. On a through-fastened roof you will have gone round the screws once somewhere in there, which is a day’s work, not a roof.

With shingles, you buy one roof and then most of another. A shingle roof laid today is due somewhere between year twenty and year thirty. Most people in north Missouri land nearer twenty than thirty.

And the second shingle roof is not just the shingles again. It is:

  • The tear-off — two to three crew days on our jobs, on top of the days it takes to lay the new one.
  • A dumpster, from a fourteen-yard up to a forty depending on the house.
  • Whatever the tear-off finds. Twenty-five years of weather sometimes turns up decking that needs replacing, and you do not know until it is open.

So the honest comparison is not “metal against shingles.” It is one metal roof against one shingle roof plus a tear-off plus a second shingle roof.

Where the money actually sits today

For what it is worth, the trade puts asphalt shingles at $1.50 to $6 a square foot installed and metal at $4 to $30, with labor about 60% of either. The metal range is that wide because it runs from an ag panel on a shed to standing seam in copper.

Compare ours like for like — 26 gauge ag panel against a good architectural shingle — and metal costs more up front but not by the multiple people expect. We are happy to price you both on the same roof so you can see it rather than take our word for it, and that is worth asking any roofer for.

So which one do you actually want?

Shingles make sense if:

  • You are likely to move inside ten or fifteen years. You will never see the second roof, so you would be buying it for somebody else.
  • The budget today is the binding constraint. A good shingle roof properly laid is a perfectly sound roof.
  • The roof is cut up with a lot of valleys, dormers and odd angles. Shingles are more forgiving of complicated shapes, and the labor difference narrows.
  • You are matching the rest of a street or a subdivision that expects shingles.

Metal makes sense if:

  • This is the place you are staying. That is the big one. If you are still here in twenty-five years, metal has already paid the difference back and is only getting further ahead.
  • You are tired of thinking about the roof. Metal is the closest a roof gets to being finished.
  • Hail is on your mind. Metal dents; shingles lose granules and then lose their life. Some insurers price the two differently — worth a call to your agent, and it is a question for them, not for us.
  • You want a building to look a particular way. A standing seam or a striated panel changes how a house reads from the road in a way shingles do not.

And yes, the rain

Somebody always brings this up, so let us deal with it. Metal roofs are loud in the rain.

On a bare pole barn, with nothing between you and the panel but air, that is true. Plenty of people count it as one of the better things about a shop.

On a house it is a different animal. There is a deck, a barrier, battens, an air gap, insulation and a ceiling between you and the sky, and by the time rain has been through all of that it is a sound rather than a drumming. People who move into a metal-roofed house expecting a racket are usually surprised.

Which is worth noticing on its own: nobody has ever asked us what rain sounds like on a shingle roof. It makes a noise too. It is just that nobody ever thought to wonder about it.

The three things that decide it more than the material

  1. How long you are staying. Said three times because it matters more than everything else on this page.
  2. What the deck is like. A roof over bad decking fails early whatever is on top. If yours is soft, that is the first line of the budget, not an afterthought.
  3. The detail at the valleys, the walls and the fasteners. Roofs almost never fail in the middle of a panel or the middle of a shingle field. They fail where two planes meet and where something penetrates. Ask whoever is quoting you how they handle those, and you will learn more than the material name tells you.

What we would actually do

If you are staying put, metal, in 26 gauge — we do not build in anything thinner, and the reason is that thin metal dents if you look at it.

If you are moving inside a decade, shingles, and spend the difference somewhere you will actually enjoy it.

If you are on the fence, ask us for both prices on your roof. We will give you the two numbers side by side and we will not lean on you. It is a thirty-year decision and you should make it with the numbers in front of you, not in a driveway conversation.

And if you are replacing shingles with metal, you may not need the tear-off at all — we have written that one up separately.

Call us and we will come and look at it.

Next step

Tell Us About Your Project!

We understand that investing in a build is a big decision. We offer a complimentary consultation where we will gather the scope of your project, ideal timeline, and budget.