Most people price siding by looking up what a box of it costs. That number turns out to be a small part of the answer.
On a re-side of ours, the labor came to more than the material did — and inside the material, the trim, soffit, house wrap and fascia came to more than the siding panels themselves. So two houses clad in identical vinyl can be thousands apart, and neither builder has done anything wrong.
Here is what actually sits in the number.
Labor is the bigger half
On a house re-side we quoted, the labor to strip the old siding and hang the new ran about 60% more than all the material put together.
That is not padding. A re-side is:
- Getting the old siding off and into a dumpster
- Finding out what is behind it
- Wrapping the house
- Cutting and fitting every corner, window, door, soffit and gable
- Doing it off ladders or a lift, on a wall two stories up
The panels go on quickly. Everything that is not a flat wall is where the days go, which is why a plain ranch and a cut-up two-story with six gables are not the same job even at the same square footage.
The trim costs more than the siding
This is the one that surprises people, and it is straight off one of our own material lists for a house re-side:
- Siding panels — one number.
- Soffit, J-channel, corner posts, starter strip, undersill, fascia and house wrap — more than that number. About half again as much.
Every window gets J-channel. Every corner gets a post. Every eave gets soffit and fascia. A house with a lot of openings and angles buys a lot of trim, and trim is not cheap per foot.
So when you compare two siding quotes, look at whether the trim, soffit and fascia are in both of them. That single line is where most of the gap between a cheap quote and a real one lives.
Prefinished or paint it yourself — about 15%
We have quoted the same house both ways: LP prefinished lap siding, or the same lap siding unfinished with the homeowner painting it after.
Prefinished came in about 15% higher on the whole job. The material was about a third more; the labor was about 9% more, because prefinished boards get handled more carefully and every cut end gets treated.
Fifteen percent to never paint a house is a real decision, not an obvious one. Worth knowing before you decide:
- Painting a whole house yourself is not a weekend, and it has to happen fairly soon after the siding goes on, not next spring.
- A factory finish is baked on and warranted. A brush finish is not.
- If you were going to hire the painting out anyway, the prefinished option is usually cheaper than the two jobs separately.
The case for unfinished is a straight one: if you will genuinely do the painting, that 15% is yours to keep.
What the panels come to on our quotes
Per square foot of wall, material only, as it lands on one of our quotes:
| Material, per sq ft | |
|---|---|
| Vinyl | about $1.35 to $2.15 |
| LP prefinished panel | about $3.70 |
So the jump from a standard vinyl to an engineered wood panel is roughly double, and up to nearly three times, the material — and because material is the smaller half of the job, it moves the finished price by a good deal less than that.
Fiber cement we buy per job rather than carrying a price, so there is no figure of ours to publish. Same with the metal board-and-batten we put on shops and houses.
The four materials, and what each is for
Installed costs and lifespans below are the trade’s published ranges, not ours — labeled that way on purpose, because they cover the whole country and we only build in one corner of it.
Vinyl — $4 to $9 a square foot installed, 20 to 40 years. The value option and there is nothing wrong with it. Never painted, never stained. It can crack in a hard freeze if something hits it, and the cheap grades show every ripple in the wall behind. Gauge matters here the same way it does on a metal roof.
Engineered wood, LP SmartSide — $5 to $13, 20 to 30 years. Looks like wood, cuts like wood, holds a finish, and comes prefinished if you want it. A popular middle ground and what a lot of our siding work is.
Fiber cement, James Hardie — $6 to $15, 30 to 50 years. The longest-lived of the common choices and the most labor to hang — it is heavy, it is brittle until it is fastened, and cutting it is a job. That labor is why the installed range runs so far above the material.
Metal board-and-batten — $7 to $16, 40 to 60 years. What we put on shops, garages and a lot of houses around here. Same 26 gauge steel as our roofs, same color options, and it does not rot, split, or need painting. It dents if something hits it hard enough, and that is about the size of its downside.
What a re-side adds that new construction does not
A new house gets siding on bare, square, dry sheathing. A re-side does not, and these lines belong in the quote:
- Tear-off labor. Covered above, and it is real days.
- A dumpster — around $1,900 on our re-sides.
- A lift or scaffold on anything tall — around $2,350.
- House wrap, which costs about nine cents a square foot and is the only thing between weather and your sheathing. It is the cheapest important item on the entire job.
- Whatever is behind the old siding. Soft sheathing, rotten trim around a window, a wall that was never flashed. Nobody knows until it is off.
Ask what happens to the price if bad sheathing turns up. A builder who has thought about that has an answer ready.
What we would actually do
- The house gets wrapped properly and the openings get flashed, whatever goes over the top. This is the part that decides whether the wall is still sound in twenty years, and it costs almost nothing compared to everything else.
- The material gets picked for how long you are staying, the same as a roof. Vinyl on a house you will sell in ten years is a sound decision. Fiber cement or metal on the place you intend to die in is a sound decision. Paying for fifty-year siding on a five-year house is not.
- The trim gets quoted as its own line, so you can see it. If a quote does not break it out, ask.
- Then the color, which is the part everybody starts with and the part that costs the least to change your mind about.
If you tell us the house and what you are trying to get out of it, we will price you two materials on the same wall so you can see the difference rather than take our word for it.
Ones we have done
- A new house near Laredo framed, roofed and clad in concrete lap siding.
- A remodel and new garage at Plattsburg in white board-and-batten metal, soffits and fascia matched to it.
Call us and we will come and look at it.