What will my project cost? It depends on about nine choices

CK's Construction

The honest answer is that nobody can price your job from a sentence, and anybody who gives you a number over the phone is guessing. But that is not much use to you stood there trying to work out whether you can afford it.

So here is the useful version. The choices that move the number are the same on almost every job, there are about nine of them, and we can tell you what each one costs. Work down this list and you will land within a few thousand of your own number before anybody comes out.

Every figure below is what a customer pays us, from our own jobs over the last six months in north Missouri.

First, the thing that explains everything: the allowance

Most of the difference between two quotes for the same building is not the building. It is the allowance.

An allowance is the budget written into the quote for something you have not picked yet. Our flooring allowance is $6 a square foot — that is what you have to spend on the flooring itself when you go and choose it. Our tile allowance is $10 a square foot.

Pick something at that number and the quote is the quote. Pick something pricier and you pay the difference. Pick something cheaper and you get it back.

This is why a builder can quote you a house for less than the man down the road and end up costing more. Ask every builder what his allowances are before you compare his price to anybody’s. A low allowance is not a low price. It is a bill you have not had yet.

1. The floor you stand the building on

This is the biggest single fork in the road and it happens before anything is built.

  • A four-inch slab runs around $8 a square foot with us, labor and material together. Published ranges across the country put a slab anywhere from $5 to $16, so we sit at the sensible end of that.
  • Five inches is about $9, and six inches just under $10. That is roughly a dollar a foot per extra inch, which matches what the trade publishes nationally.
  • Footings, where you need them, run about $69 a linear foot for a twelve-inch by three-foot footer. Concrete piers for a porch are about $125 apiece.
  • A full basement is a different animal. Nationally an unfinished basement runs $20 to $50 a square foot, and on a 2,000 square foot house that is $30,000 to $70,000 more than a slab. Finishing it afterwards is another $30 to $50 a foot on top.

On a 2,400 square foot shop, going from four inches to six costs you about $4,000. If a loaded truck or a hoist is ever going in there, spend it. If it is hay and a mower, do not.

2. Cabinets

The gap here is bigger than most people expect, and it is priced by the linear foot of cabinet, not by the room.

  • Prefab cabinetry, soft-close hinges and slides included, installed: around $700 a linear foot.
  • Custom paint-grade, built for the room it goes in: around $850 a linear foot.

A typical kitchen, utility, mudroom and bathroom package is 55 to 60 linear feet. So the whole-house difference between prefab and custom is roughly $8,000. A bigger house with a pantry and a great-room build-out runs to 90 linear feet and the gap widens with it.

Neither is the wrong answer. Prefab is genuinely good now. But it is an $8,000 decision, not a taste decision, and it is worth knowing that before you are stood in a showroom.

3. Countertops

Granite or quartzite in the first price group runs about $87 a square foot installed. A kitchen, a utility room, a pantry and four vanities comes to around 150 square feet, so call it $13,000 for the house.

Move up a price group and that climbs quickly. This is one of the easiest places to add $5,000 of stone without noticing.

4. Flooring — and why the price at the store is not the price of the floor

Here is where the allowance really shows itself.

At Home Depot or Lowe’s, luxury vinyl plank runs roughly $1 to $2 a square foot for builder grade, $2.50 to $4 for the mid-range most people actually want, and $5 to $8 for premium. Our $6 allowance buys you a floor at the top of the mid-range or the bottom of premium. It is not a cheap floor.

Installed, on our jobs, flooring lands around $14 to $15 a square foot — LVP, engineered hardwood and carpet all come out within a dollar of each other once they are down, because most of that number is not the plank. It is preparing the subfloor, the underlayment, the waste, the transitions, the trim and the man doing it.

That is the single most misleading number in building. You see $3 a square foot on a shelf and think a 1,500 foot house is $4,500 of floor. Installed, it is nearer $22,000.

What that means for your decision: on 1,500 square feet, choosing a $9 floor instead of the $6 allowance adds about $4,500 to the job. Choosing a $3 floor takes about $4,500 off it.

5. Tile

Tile is the most labor-heavy surface in a house, and the figures show it.

Our tile allowance is $10 a square foot for the tile itself. Installed — with the backer board, the waterproofing membrane, mortar, grout, sealer and a niche in the shower — it comes to around $44 a square foot.

A kitchen backsplash, two bathroom floors, a master bath and a tiled shower is about 370 square feet with waste, so $16,000 of the job. If the budget is tight, tile is where you find money fastest.

6. Siding — a ten thousand dollar decision hiding in plain sight

Siding is priced per square foot of wall, not floor, so it scales with how tall and how spread out you build. A rough way to get your wall area: walk the perimeter of the building, multiply by the wall height, and take a little off for the doors and windows. A thirty by fifty house is about 1,400 square feet of wall.

Here is what the material comes to on one of our quotes:

  • Builder vinyl — about $1.35 a square foot.
  • Better vinyl (a heavier panel, deeper color, better warranty) — about $2.15 a square foot.
  • Engineered wood panel (LP SmartSide and the like) — $2.50 to $2.85 a square foot depending on the panel, and about $3.70 if you want it prefinished from the factory rather than painted on site.
  • Fiber cement (Hardie board and its relatives) we order per house rather than off a shelf, because it is cut to the building.

For context, the same products sell retail at $1.50 to $4.50 a square foot for builder vinyl and $2 to $4.50 for engineered wood, material only, before anybody hangs it.

Installed is the number that matters, and it is not ours to publish, because we bid siding labor per house rather than per square foot — a simple gable with two corners is not the same job as a house with six roof lines and a wraparound porch, and pretending otherwise is how a builder ends up eating a week. What we can tell you is where the trade lands nationally:

Installed, per square foot
Vinyl $3.50 – $9
Engineered wood $4.50 – $11
Steel $5.50 – $12
Cedar $6 – $16
Fiber cement $8 – $16

On 1,400 square feet of wall, that is roughly $5,000 for vinyl against $15,000 or more for fiber cement. Same house, same square footage, same crew. That is why siding is worth thinking about before you fall in love with a picture.

A word about cedar, because people ask

Cedar comes up in nearly every porch conversation, and it is worth being clear about what it is and is not.

We do not sell cedar as a wall covering priced by the square foot. Where cedar earns its money is overhead and in the open — posts, beams, exposed rafters and a tongue-and-groove ceiling on a porch or a covered deck. It is the material people are actually picturing when they say they want a porch that looks like something, and it is priced by the stick, not by the square foot.

Roughly, from us:

  • A 6x6 cedar post runs $220 to $350 depending on length.
  • A 6x12 cedar beam runs from about $456 at eight feet to $1,800 at twenty-four. That is the number that surprises people. One long beam over an opening can cost more than a whole wall of vinyl.
  • Cedar rafters for a covered deck are around $150 apiece at twelve feet, set two feet on center.
  • A cedar ceiling and soffit is 1x6 boards at $43 to $62 each depending on length, and a covered deck eats fifty or sixty of them.

None of that is expensive for what it is. But a cedar porch is a five-figure decision sitting quietly inside a house budget, and it is better to know that in the drawing stage than at framing.

If the look matters more than the species, ask us about white pine beams. They are a fraction of the cedar and they take a stain.

7. Windows — the same hole in the wall, three times the price

Windows are the one place where two houses that look identical from the road can be fifteen thousand dollars apart, and almost nobody counts them.

From our own recent jobs, a window costs us — and therefore you — about:

  • $375 to $450 for a standard white vinyl double-hung in a common size.
  • $650 to $700 for a better vinyl unit, bigger, better glass.
  • $1,000 and up for a black clad window from a name brand.

Nationally the same ladder reads $150 to $400 installed for builder grade, $400 to $700 for mid-range, and $700 to well past $1,000 for premium, so our numbers are ordinary. The point is not that any of them is wrong. The point is the multiplier.

A twenty-window house is a $7,500 house in builder vinyl and a $22,000 house in black clad. Nothing else about it changes.

Three things people get caught by:

  1. A double counts as two and a triple counts as three. When you draw a wide window over the kitchen sink, you have not drawn one window.
  2. Transoms, direct-set picture units and anything not a rectangle price differently from the double-hung you were quoting in your head.
  3. Black costs more than white, in every brand, in every material. It is worth it to a lot of people. It is not free to anybody.

Count your openings before you compare two builders’ window numbers. If one man priced you eighteen and the other priced you twenty-two, you are not comparing windows, you are comparing arithmetic.

8 and 9. Roof and site work

  • Roof. Metal or shingles is a thirty-year decision, not a today decision. We have written that one up separately.
  • Site work. Dirt, the drive, the septic, getting power to it. Almost never in a builder’s headline number — ours or anybody’s — and it can be five figures on a bad site.

How to use all of this

  1. Work out your square footage.
  2. Pick your slab thickness and decide about a basement. That is the biggest fork and it is nearly always the right place to spend or save.
  3. Take our allowances as your starting point and decide honestly where you are going to go over them. Most people go over on the kitchen.
  4. Count your window openings — remembering a double is two — and pick a grade.
  5. Work out your wall area and pick a siding.
  6. Add site work, because it is real and it is not in the number.
  7. Call us and we will tell you how close you got.

What we would actually do

We put our allowances in writing on the quote, in the same document, so you can see what we have budgeted for the things you have not picked yet. If you want a cheaper floor we will price it. If you want a pricier one we will tell you what it does to the total before you commit, not after.

And if you tell us your number, we will tell you plainly whether it builds what you are describing. Sometimes the honest answer is a smaller building done properly, and we would rather say that in September than in February.

Next step

Tell Us About Your Project!

We understand that investing in a build is a big decision. We offer a complimentary consultation where we will gather the scope of your project, ideal timeline, and budget.