Most leaks are not the roof failing. They are one detail failing — a pipe boot, a ridge, a trim where two planes meet, a skylight. The roof around it is usually fine.
Most, not all. Hail, a hard straight-line wind, and plain old age all end roofs around here every year, and a roof that has genuinely reached the end is not a repair job at any price. Both things are true, and telling them apart is the whole exercise.
The money says why it matters. A repair on our jobs typically runs somewhere between $1,000 and $3,500. A new roof is a different conversation entirely.
Here is how to tell which one you are looking at.
First, before anything else
While it is still wet:
- Catch the water. A bucket, and a small hole poked in a bulging ceiling so it drains in one place instead of bringing the whole thing down.
- Move what matters out from under it.
- Photograph it, inside and out, with the date. Photographs taken while it is actually leaking are worth a great deal later — to us, and to your insurer if it comes to that.
- Stay off the roof. A wet roof is how people get hurt, and a metal one in the rain is worse than it looks. Whatever is up there will still be up there when it dries.
Then ring somebody. A leak that has run once will run again, and what it is doing to the sheathing between rainfalls is the expensive part.
Where leaks actually come from
Not the middle of the roof. Almost never the middle of the roof.
We pulled a real repair order of ours — a metal roof, leaking, fixed for well under three thousand dollars. Here is the entire scope:
- New boots on every pipe. Rubber pipe boots harden, crack and pull away. They are the single most common leak on any roof, metal or shingle, and they are cheap.
- Vented closures under the ridge. The gap at the very top, where the ridge cap sits over the panel ribs. Wrong closure or no closure and weather drives straight in.
- Sealant under the transition trim. Anywhere the roof changes pitch or meets a wall. Two planes meeting is a joint, and joints leak.
- The skylights replaced with solid metal. More on that below.
On a shingle roof it is the same list wearing different clothes: boots, flashing at walls and chimneys, valleys, and the ridge.
If somebody looks at a leak and their first answer is “you need a new roof,” ask them which of those four it is. A roofer who has actually been up there can tell you.
The skylight problem
Those translucent panels that let daylight into a shop are the shortest-lived thing on the roof. They go brittle, they craze, they crack, and they leak — while the metal either side of them is still perfectly sound.
We fix that two ways:
- Replace the panels. Fine if you want the light. It is a real job — one of ours ran to a couple of dozen panels and a full crew day, and the labor was about half the price.
- Replace them with solid metal. Cheaper, permanent, and it is what that repair order above did. You lose the daylight and you stop thinking about it.
If a shop roof is leaking and it has light panels in it, that is the first place to look.
When it is the roof, not a detail
Three things genuinely finish a roof: hail, wind, and age. Here is what each one looks like, so you can form your own view before anybody gives you theirs.
Hail
On shingles, hail is real damage. It knocks the granules off and bruises the mat underneath, and once the granules are gone the shingle ages fast whether or not it is leaking yet. What to look for:
- Granules in the gutters and piled at the bottom of the downspout.
- Dark, soft-looking divots scattered across the shingle, roughly the size of the stones that fell.
- Dings in the soft metal you can reach from the ground — gutters, vents, window wrap, the fins on the air conditioner. That is the honest proxy. If the gutters took a beating, the roof did too.
On a metal roof, hail is usually cosmetic. It dents the flat of the panel and the roof carries on shedding water exactly as before. It is worth looking at the coating and the trim, but a dented steel roof is generally still a roof. That difference is one of the real arguments for metal here, and we have put it alongside the rest of the comparison here.
High wind
Wind does not push on the middle of a roof. It gets under an edge and peels, so damage starts at the rakes, the eaves and the ridge.
- On shingles: lifted or missing tabs, usually along one edge. A creased shingle is damaged even though it is still up there — the seal is broken and it will go in the next blow.
- On metal: panels lifted at an edge, screws backed out in a line, ridge cap or rake trim peeled back.
- Look at the big doors too. On a shop or barn, the overhead door is the weakest thing in the building in a high wind. If it lets go, the building fills with air and the pressure comes off the inside of the roof — which is why we quote wind bracing and windload-rated doors on the larger openings rather than treating them as an upsell.
Age
Nothing dramatic happened; it just got old. Shingles here tend to give twenty-something years, steel forty and up.
- On shingles: granules gone across the whole roof, not in patches. Curling and cupping everywhere. Bare, shiny spots. Brittle enough that walking on it breaks it.
- On a through-fastened metal roof: screws backing out across the whole roof, and rubber washers gone hard and cracked. That happens somewhere around the fifteen to twenty year mark and it is a maintenance job, not a failure — going round the screws once buys the rest of the roof’s life. If nobody ever does it, it eventually becomes a failure.
- Either kind: rust or staining at the cut edges, seams opening, and a deck that gives underfoot.
One failing detail on a sound roof is a repair. Any of the three above, happening across the whole roof, is not.
If a storm just went through
Photograph it, with the date, before anything is touched or cleaned up — the same photographs help us and help your insurer. Then let it dry out and get somebody up there.
A word on the trucks that appear after a hailstorm. Every big storm in this part of the state brings crews from a long way off, knocking doors and offering to handle everything. Some are perfectly good. Some are gone by spring, and the warranty goes with them. A roof is a twenty-year decision and a doorstep is a poor place to make one — there is no harm in taking a day and ringing somebody who will still be here.
Repair or replace — the honest test
Repair it if:
- The leak is at a detail — a boot, a trim, a valley, a skylight — and the field of the roof is sound.
- The roof has years left. If yours is halfway through its life, a repair buys you the rest of it.
- There is one leak, or two. One failure is a failure. Five is a pattern.
- The deck underneath is still solid.
Replace it if:
- The field of the roof is going — shingles curling and shedding granules, fasteners backing out across the whole roof, seams opening.
- Hail or wind took the whole roof, not one edge of it. Scattered damage across every slope is a different problem from three lifted shingles on the west rake.
- You are chasing leaks. Three repairs in two years is a new roof bought on the installment plan, and the water damage in between is not free.
- The decking is soft. Covering bad decking is money spent to hide a problem.
- It is near the end anyway. Spending real money on a roof with three years left is a hard sum to make work.
The one that decides it more than any of the above: how long are you staying. We have written the thirty-year version of that here.
What a repair costs
Our small roof repairs generally land between $1,000 and $3,500, all in.
That band covers a surprising amount:
- A shingle repair with a bundle of shingles, a bundle of ridge cap and the sealant to go with it — around $2,000 on a real job of ours.
- A metal repair replacing a run of panel and the trim around it — 150 feet of 26 gauge, new gutter apron, rat guard and rake — around $2,300, roughly half material and half labor.
- The four-point metal roof repair described above — boots, ridge closures, transition sealant and the skylights — under $3,000.
Labor is about half of a repair, which is why a small repair does not scale down as far as people expect. Getting a crew, a ladder and equipment to your place costs what it costs whether the fix takes an hour or a day. It is also why doing three known problems in one visit is far cheaper than three visits.
What we would actually do
- Get somebody up there who will tell you what they found, with photographs, before anybody talks about price.
- Fix the detail if the roof is sound. We would rather sell you a $2,000 repair that holds than a roof you did not need.
- Say so plainly if it is not. If the field is going, a repair is money thrown at a roof that is leaving anyway, and we will tell you that too.
- Look inside as well as on top. The attic tells you how long it has been going on, which is usually longer than the stain suggests.
On insurance: if this came from a storm or hail, that is a conversation with your agent and not with us, and it is worth having early — most policies have a window for reporting storm damage. We will document what we find and give you photographs. What is and is not covered is between you and them — we do not advise on it and we would be wary of anybody in our trade who does.
One local note
Most of the counties we work in have no county building permit for roof work at all, which we have written up here. Nobody is coming to check the repair on your behalf. That makes it worth knowing what was actually done, in writing, before you pay for it.
Roofs we have put right
- A reroof at Platte City
- A metal roof at Gallatin
- A house reroof at Savannah, brown metal and matching trims.
Call us and we will come and look at it.